When buying insurance in Canada, you'll encounter both insurance brokers and insurance agents. They play different roles and have different obligations. Understanding who works for whom can save you money and ensure you get the right coverage. This guide explains the key differences and when to use each.
An insurance agent (also called a direct writer or captive agent) represents a single insurance company. They sell only that company's products and have a primary duty to the insurer. Examples include a State Farm agent who sells only State Farm policies, or an employee of Desjardins who sells only Desjardins products. Agents know their company's products deeply but cannot compare the market.
An insurance broker is an independent professional licensed to access multiple insurance companies. Brokers work for the client, not the insurer. They shop the market on your behalf, compare coverage and pricing from multiple companies, and provide advice based on your specific needs. In Canada, the majority of insurance is sold through brokers.
Both agents and brokers are typically paid commission by the insurance company when a policy is placed. This means you generally don't pay directly for their advice. Broker commissions vary by line of business: home and auto typically 10–20%, life insurance 30–100% of first-year premium (with lower renewals). Fee-based insurance consulting is rare but available for complex commercial risks.
Both brokers and agents must be licensed in each province where they operate. Provincial regulators (FSRA in Ontario, BCFSA in BC, AMF in Quebec, etc.) set licensing requirements, continuing education standards, and enforce professional conduct rules. Both are required to act in good faith and provide accurate information.
Use a broker when: you want the market compared, you have complex needs, you're buying commercial insurance, or you want independent advice. Use a direct insurer or agent when: you've done your research, you already know you want a specific company, or you prefer the convenience of online direct purchase.
In life and benefits insurance, the equivalent distinction is between "tied" advisors (employed by a single carrier) and independent advisors or MGAs (managing general agents) who access multiple companies. For complex life insurance planning, an independent advisor who can access multiple carriers typically provides better advice and more competitive pricing.
KOHO offers free banking with no monthly fees. Use code 45ET55JSYA for a bonus when you sign up.
Open KOHO Free — No Fees — Code 45ET55JSYA