Many Canadian real estate investors eventually consider incorporating a holding company to own their properties. While the tax savings pitched by some advisors sound compelling, the reality is more nuanced. Rental income in a corporation is taxed at high rates, and incorporating real estate is not automatically advantageous. Here's an honest assessment of when a holding company makes sense.
Instead of owning properties personally, you set up a corporation (often an Ontario numbered company or named corporation) that purchases and holds the real estate. The corporation receives rental income, pays expenses, and retains profits — or pays them to you as salary or dividends.
This means simply incorporating to "save tax" on rental income generally doesn't work. The tax savings come from other strategies enabled by the corporate structure.
If your corporation also earns active business income (say, a property management company or renovation business), that income may qualify for the small business deduction (~11% combined federal/provincial rate). You can retain those earnings in the corporation and invest them in real estate — the timing arbitrage (paying 11% now vs. 50% at withdrawal) is significant if you don't need the personal income immediately.
Properties owned in a corporation provide a layer of personal liability protection. A tenant injury lawsuit against the corporation generally cannot reach your personal assets (though banks almost always require personal guarantees on mortgages, limiting this protection for financing purposes).
Shares of a corporation are easier to gift, sell, or transfer in a will than real property directly. A family trust owning shares of a holding company that owns real estate can provide significant flexibility for income splitting (subject to TOSI rules) and estate planning — particularly for high-net-worth families.
The Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption (LCGE) doesn't apply to rental real estate directly. But if structured correctly, shares of a corporation that qualifies as a Small Business Corporation (SBC) may be eligible for the LCGE. This requires that 90%+ of the corporation's assets be used in active business — difficult for pure rental holding companies, but potentially achievable with careful planning.
If you want to transfer existing properties into a corporation without triggering immediate capital gains, a Section 85 rollover election may defer the gain until the corporation sells the property. This is a complex tax transaction requiring a tax specialist and often a business valuator. Not all properties are suitable candidates — particularly those with large existing gains.
Every dollar saved on bank fees improves your returns. KOHO offers free banking with no monthly fees. Use code 45ET55JSYA for a bonus when you open your account.
Open KOHO Free — Code 45ET55JSYA