💰 Bremo

TFSA vs FHSA Canada Comparison 2025

The First Home Savings Account launched in 2023 with unique advantages for first-time buyers. Here is how it compares to the TFSA and which to prioritize.

Free Banking to Maximize Your TFSA Contributions

Stop paying bank fees — every dollar saved goes into your TFSA. Code 45ET55JSYA = $20 bonus.

Open KOHO Free — Code 45ET55JSYA

Full Comparison: TFSA vs FHSA

FeatureTFSAFHSA
Who can open itAny Canadian resident 18+Canadian resident 18+, first-time home buyer*
Annual contribution limit$7,000 (2025)$8,000
Lifetime limit$95,000 (cumulative room since 2009)$40,000
Carry-forward unused roomYes — unlimited carry-forwardYes — up to $8,000 carry-forward (1 year only)
Tax deduction on contributionsNoYes — full deduction like RRSP
Tax on growth inside accountNoneNone
Tax-free withdrawals for homeYes — any withdrawal is tax-freeYes — for qualifying first home purchase
Tax on non-home withdrawalsNone — withdraw for any reason tax-freeYes — taxed as income (like RRSP withdrawal)
Repayment required after home withdrawalNoNo
Account deadlineNo deadlineMust use within 15 years of opening, or by Dec 31 of year you turn 71
Transfer option if not used for homeN/A — already flexibleCan transfer to RRSP/RRIF tax-free if not used for home
Eligible investmentsSame as RRSP — broad eligibilitySame as RRSP — broad eligibility

*First-time home buyer for FHSA purposes means you have not owned a qualifying home at any time during the current calendar year or the preceding four calendar years.

The FHSA's Unique Advantage: Double Tax Savings

The FHSA is often described as combining the best features of the TFSA and the RRSP for home buyers. Contributions are tax-deductible (like an RRSP) and qualifying home purchase withdrawals are completely tax-free (like a TFSA). This means you get a tax refund on the way in AND pay no tax on the way out — a "double tax savings" that neither the TFSA nor the RRSP provides on its own.

For someone in a 40% marginal tax bracket contributing $8,000 to an FHSA: they get a $3,200 tax refund immediately, and when they withdraw the funds (plus growth) for a home purchase, they pay no tax. That is $3,200 effectively free money plus tax-free compounding.

When the TFSA Beats the FHSA

The Recommended Order for First-Time Buyers

Bottom line: If you are a first-time home buyer, open both an FHSA and a TFSA. Max the FHSA first for the deduction, then put additional home savings into your TFSA. The two accounts are complementary, not competing.

What Happens to the FHSA If You Never Buy a Home?

If you open an FHSA and never buy a qualifying home, you can transfer the entire balance (contributions + growth) to your RRSP or RRIF at any time before the account's deadline, with no tax consequences at the time of transfer. It simply becomes RRSP savings. The FHSA is essentially a risk-free account — if you don't use it for a home, it rolls into your retirement savings.

Save More for Your TFSA — Zero Fees

KOHO's free banking helps you hit your TFSA contribution limit faster. Code 45ET55JSYA = $20 bonus.

Start Saving Free with KOHO