CIBC and TD are both Big 5 Canadian banks with similar fee structures, but they have meaningful differences in student accounts, digital banking, investing costs, credit card rewards, and mortgage products. This comparison gives you a clear picture of which bank offers more for your specific banking situation.
Comparing fee tiers directly:
At the entry level, CIBC's basic account is slightly pricier than TD's. For unlimited banking, the accounts are identically priced with the same $4,000 minimum balance waiver. The CIBC Smart Account's graduated pricing structure (where the fee automatically caps at $16.95 as you exceed the included transactions) is unique and can work in your favor if your transaction volume varies month to month.
CIBC's Student Account offers unlimited transactions and unlimited e-Transfers completely free — one of the most generous student banking offers among the Big 5. TD's Student Account includes only 25 monthly transactions, which can be limiting for active digital banking. For post-secondary students, CIBC's student account is a clear advantage over TD.
TD's extended banking hours are a consistent advantage over CIBC, which maintains more traditional banking hours. Many TD locations are open until 7-8pm on weekdays and throughout the day on weekends. If you can only visit a bank outside standard 9-to-5 business hours, TD is the more accessible choice.
Both CIBC and TD have well-rated mobile apps with full feature sets. CIBC has been a first-mover on digital payment methods — it was among the first Canadian banks to support Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Samsung Pay simultaneously. TD's app is slightly better-rated overall in App Store reviews, but the gap is small. Both apps support mobile deposit, e-Transfers, bill payment, and investment management.
CIBC's Smart Account graduated fee structure shows a design-thinking approach to banking that TD hasn't matched. CIBC also integrates well with Simplii Financial's platform for clients who use both.
CIBC Investor's Edge charges $6.95 per trade — the lowest per-trade fee among all Big 5 bank-owned brokerages. TD Direct Investing charges $9.95 per trade. For active investors who make 10 trades per month, that's a difference of $30/month or $360/year in commission savings. If you're doing any self-directed investing within a big bank brokerage, CIBC's lower trading costs are a meaningful advantage. For robo-advisory investing, both charge 0.5% annually — identical.
TD's credit card portfolio is stronger than CIBC's for most Canadians. The TD First Class Travel Visa Infinite and TD Cash Back Visa Infinite consistently rank at the top of Canadian credit card comparison sites. CIBC's Aventura program offers good travel redemption but doesn't have the same breadth of partner transfer options or earn rates as TD's best travel cards. For cashback, TD's offerings are also slightly superior. If your credit card rewards are a key banking consideration, TD wins this round.
TD's massive US banking presence — 1,100+ US branches and 2,600+ ATMs — is a significant advantage for Canadians with any US banking needs. CIBC does operate CIBC Bank USA, but its US footprint is far smaller than TD's. For snowbirds, frequent US travellers, or those with US-dollar income, TD offers a genuinely superior cross-border banking experience.
Both CIBC and TD offer fixed, variable, and adjustable-rate mortgages with competitive Big 5 pricing. TD's Home Equity FlexLine and CIBC's Home Power Plan both combine a mortgage with a revolving line of credit. They are functionally similar products. Both banks have similarly structured break penalties. CIBC has invested in making its mortgage application process more digital-friendly, which may mean a faster application experience. For pure rate comparison, rates between the two banks are typically within basis points of each other for the same terms and qualifications.
CIBC owns Simplii Financial, a no-fee digital bank that shares CIBC's ATM network. Many Canadians bank with Simplii for free daily transactions and maintain a CIBC relationship for mortgages or investing. This is a unique advantage of the CIBC ecosystem — you can essentially get free daily banking AND access to CIBC's mortgage and investing products by using both brands. TD does not have an equivalent free banking subsidiary.
KOHO offers free banking with no monthly fees and no minimum balance — available to all Canadians. Use code 45ET55JSYA for a bonus when you sign up.
Open KOHO Free — No Fees — Code 45ET55JSYATD wins for most everyday Canadian banking customers in 2025, primarily because of extended banking hours, superior credit card rewards, and excellent US banking access. CIBC has specific advantages that make it the better choice in the right situations — particularly for students, self-directed investors, and those who want to leverage the CIBC/Simplii Financial dual-bank setup. Neither bank should be your choice if minimizing banking fees is your top priority. Both charge $16.95/month for their unlimited accounts, and no-fee alternatives can handle daily transactions for free.