HELOC vs Personal Loan in Canada 2025

Key difference: A HELOC is secured by your home and offers much lower interest rates (prime + ~0.5%) but requires home equity. A personal loan is unsecured, faster to obtain, and doesn't put your home at risk — but rates run 6%–20%+ depending on your credit.

When you need to borrow money in Canada, two common options are a home equity line of credit (HELOC) and a personal loan. Both can fund renovations, debt consolidation, or major expenses — but they differ significantly in cost, risk, and eligibility. Here's how to choose the right one.

Quick Comparison

Feature	HELOC	Personal Loan
Security	Secured (home)	Unsecured
Typical rate	Prime + 0.5% (~5.45%)	6%–20%+
Borrowing limit	Up to 65% of home value	Typically $5K–$50K
Repayment	Revolving; interest-only minimum	Fixed monthly payments
Home equity needed	Yes (20%+ equity)	No
Approval speed	1–3 weeks	1–5 business days
Risk to home	Yes	No
Tax-deductible interest	If used to invest	Rarely

When a HELOC Is the Better Choice

You need a large amount ($50,000+) that personal loans can't cover
You have substantial home equity and want the lowest possible rate
You want a revolving credit facility for ongoing expenses (staged reno)
You're using the Smith Manoeuvre for tax-deductible investing
You can discipline yourself not to over-borrow against your home

When a Personal Loan Is the Better Choice

You don't own a home or don't have enough equity
You want a fixed payment schedule to stay disciplined
The amount is small ($5,000–$25,000) and a HELOC setup isn't worth it
You want to protect your home from being collateral
You need funds faster than a HELOC application allows

The Rate Gap: How Much Does Collateral Matter?

The difference in interest rates between a HELOC and a personal loan can be dramatic. On a $30,000 balance over 3 years:

Product	Rate	Monthly Payment	Total Interest
HELOC (interest only)	5.45%	$136/mo	Ongoing until repaid
Personal loan	9.99%	$968/mo	~$4,846
Personal loan	14.99%	$1,040/mo	~$7,440

The HELOC's lower rate is compelling — but the interest-only minimum means you must be proactive about paying down principal, otherwise the balance lingers.

Hybrid strategy: Some Canadians get a HELOC for the lower rate but treat it like a personal loan — setting up automatic monthly payments that include principal. This way you get the rate advantage without the risk of interest-only complacency.

Credit Score Requirements

Both products require a reasonable credit score, but thresholds differ:

HELOC: Typically requires 650–680 minimum; best rates at 720+. Also requires home equity and stress test qualification.
Personal loan: Some lenders approve at 600+; online lenders may go lower. No stress test required.

Impact on Your Home

This is the most important consideration. A HELOC is registered against your property title. If you default, the lender can begin foreclosure proceedings. A personal loan default leads to collections and credit damage — serious, but your home isn't on the line.

For many Canadians, especially those with significant home equity, the risk feels manageable. But during periods of income disruption (job loss, illness), the secured nature of a HELOC becomes a real concern.

Free Up Cash Flow While You Manage Your Home Equity

Stop paying monthly bank fees while you figure out your HELOC strategy. KOHO gives Canadian homeowners a no-fee account with cash back on spending. Use code 45ET55JSYA for a sign-up bonus.

Get KOHO Free — Use Code 45ET55JSYA

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a HELOC cheaper than a personal loan?

Almost always, yes. HELOC rates of ~5.45% are far below the 8–20% range common for unsecured personal loans in Canada.

Can I get both a HELOC and a personal loan?

Yes, there's no rule against having both. But having multiple credit facilities increases the risk of over-borrowing. Your debt-to-income ratio matters for future borrowing.

Which is better for debt consolidation?

A HELOC is generally better for debt consolidation if you own a home with sufficient equity, because the lower rate saves significant interest. The risk is treating your home as an ATM — if you run up the consolidated debts again, you've compounded your problem.