New vs Used Car in Canada 2025: Which Should You Buy?

Q: Verdict: Which Should You Buy?

For most Canadians in 2025, a 2–4 year old used vehicle offers the best financial value. The exception: if you're buying an EV, strongly consider new to capture the $5,000 federal rebate and take advantage of the latest battery technology and warranty coverage.

No fee everyday banking

Set up direct deposit and skip the monthly fee. Free to open, and the Easy plan has no monthly fee. Worth doing if you will actually move your pay or your CRA deposits over, not if the card sits unused. Code BREMO2026.

See how it works

Average new car prices in Canada have surpassed $50,000. Used cars remain a compelling option for cost-conscious buyers — but new cars offer warranties, EV rebates, and lower financing rates. Here's how to decide which makes more sense for your situation.

The Financial Case at a Glance

Factor	New Car	Used Car (3 yrs old)
Average purchase price	$45,000–$65,000	$20,000–$35,000
Year 1 depreciation	15–20% (~$8,000–$12,000)	8–10% (slower)
Financing rate (2025)	6–9% or promo rates	7–12%
Warranty	3–5 year comprehensive	Limited/none
Federal EV rebate eligible	Yes (up to $5,000)	No
Insurance cost	Higher (higher value)	Lower

The Case for Buying New

Advantages

Full manufacturer warranty (no surprises)
Latest safety features and technology
Promotional financing rates (sometimes 0%)
Eligible for iZEV EV rebates ($5,000)
No hidden history — you're the first owner
Better fuel efficiency (newer models)

Disadvantages

Much higher purchase price
Heavy depreciation in first 1–2 years
Higher insurance premiums
Higher HST/taxes at purchase
Emotionally harder to accept early damage

The Case for Buying Used

Advantages

Significantly lower purchase price
Previous owner absorbed the worst depreciation
Lower insurance costs (lower vehicle value)
Smaller loan = less financial risk
CPO (certified pre-owned) programs offer warranties

Disadvantages

Higher financing rates (1–3% more)
Unknown history (mechanical issues)
No manufacturer warranty (unless CPO)
Older tech and safety features
Lien risk on private sales

True Cost Comparison: 5 Years of Ownership

Let's compare a new $45,000 sedan vs a 3-year-old used version at $26,000, both financed over 5 years.

Cost Item	New $45,000	Used $26,000
Down payment (15%)	$6,750	$3,900
Financed amount	$38,250	$22,100
Rate / term	7.5% / 60 mo	9.5% / 60 mo
Monthly payment	~$766	~$463
Total interest paid	~$7,710	~$5,680
5-yr depreciation loss	~$22,500 (50%)	~$10,400 (40%)
Approx. 5-yr total cost	~$53,000	~$32,000

The used car saves approximately $21,000 over 5 years in this example — even accounting for higher interest rates and slightly higher maintenance costs.

When New Makes Financial Sense

You're buying an EV and want the $5,000 iZEV rebate
Manufacturer is offering 0% or sub-3% promotional financing
You plan to keep the vehicle for 8–10+ years (maximizing value)
You require reliability guarantees (long commutes, remote areas)
A certified new vehicle fits within your budget without stretching

When Used Makes Financial Sense

You want to avoid the steep first-year depreciation hit
You're on a tighter budget and need to keep monthly payments low
You want to pay cash or take a smaller loan
You find a certified pre-owned vehicle with remaining factory warranty
You're not interested in EVs and don't need the latest technology

The "Sweet Spot" Used Car: 2–4 Years Old

Automotive experts often recommend buying a vehicle that is 2–4 years old. By this point, the car has absorbed the worst of its depreciation (often 30–40% off new price) but still has modern safety tech, and many models will still have some factory warranty remaining.

Look for low-mileage lease returns (typically 20,000–24,000 km/year) — these are often in excellent condition and priced below comparable dealer-used inventory.

Don't Forget: Used Car Due Diligence in Canada

CARFAX Canada report — Check for accidents, odometer rollbacks, total loss declarations
PPSR lien search — Provincial registry to confirm no outstanding loans against the vehicle
Independent inspection — $100–$150 at a trusted mechanic before any purchase
Private sale RST (Ontario): You pay 8% RST to MTO based on book value, not sale price

Save on Gas with KOHO Cash Back

KOHO gives you cash back on gas and groceries — helping offset the cost of car ownership. No monthly fees, no minimum balance. Use code BREMO2026 for a sign-up bonus.

Get KOHO Free — Use Code BREMO2026

Verdict: Which Should You Buy?

For most Canadians in 2025, a 2–4 year old used vehicle offers the best financial value. The exception: if you're buying an EV, strongly consider new to capture the $5,000 federal rebate and take advantage of the latest battery technology and warranty coverage.

Whatever you choose, get bank pre-approval before you shop, and always negotiate the vehicle price separately from financing and trade-in value.

Last updated: March 2025. Prices and rates are approximate and will vary by make, model, and lender.