The Two Types of RESP Plans
When Canadians open an RESP, they typically choose between two fundamentally different structures: self-directed plans offered by banks and brokerages, and group (pooled) plans offered by scholarship plan dealers. The difference between these two structures has enormous implications for fees, flexibility, and how much your child ultimately receives.
| Feature | Self-Directed RESP | Group (Pooled) RESP |
|---|
| Provider examples | Wealthsimple, Questrade, TD, RBC | Heritage Education, CST, Knowledge First |
| Contribution flexibility | Contribute any amount, anytime | Fixed schedule required |
| Investment options | ETFs, stocks, GICs, mutual funds | Pooled with other subscribers |
| Fees | Low (0–0.5% MER for ETFs) | High (enrollment fees + annual fees) |
| Cancellation penalty | None | Significant — may lose contributions |
| Investment control | Full control | No individual control |
| Flexibility if child skips school | High | Very limited |
Self-Directed RESPs: The Modern Standard
A self-directed RESP is simply a Registered Education Savings Plan account held at a bank, credit union, or online brokerage where you choose what to invest in. You can contribute any amount at any time (up to the $50,000 lifetime cap), invest in whatever securities the provider offers, and close or change the plan with no penalty.
Advantages of Self-Directed RESPs
- Low fees: Invest in low-cost index ETFs with management expense ratios under 0.25%. No enrollment fees, no sales charges.
- Full flexibility: Contribute monthly, annually, or in lump sums. Change your contribution amount anytime.
- Investment choice: Pick age-appropriate portfolios — growth ETFs when the child is young, shifting to conservative as they approach 18.
- No lock-in: If circumstances change, you can withdraw your contributions with no penalty (grants must be repaid, investment income is taxed).
- Transparency: You can see exactly where your money is invested and what it's worth at all times.
Best self-directed options: Wealthsimple (managed portfolios, great for beginners), Questrade (self-directed ETF investing, lowest trading costs), TD/RBC (in-branch service, TD e-Series funds for low-cost investing).
Group (Pooled) RESPs: High Fees and Low Flexibility
Group RESPs are sold by scholarship plan dealers — companies like Heritage Education Funds, CST Consultants (now Kidsave), and Knowledge First Financial. In a group plan, your contributions are pooled with other subscribers who have children the same age, and the pool is managed by the dealer.
Warning: Group RESPs have been the subject of significant regulatory scrutiny in Canada. The Ontario Securities Commission, MFDA, and consumer advocates have repeatedly raised concerns about high fees, misleading sales practices, and rigid contribution requirements. Many families have lost substantial money by cancelling group plans early.
Problems with Group RESP Plans
- High enrollment fees: Upfront fees of $200–$500 or more are common
- Rigid contribution schedules: Missing a payment can result in penalties or plan cancellation
- Early cancellation losses: If you need to cancel early, you may lose enrollment fees and sales charges — sometimes thousands of dollars
- No investment control: You cannot choose your investments; the dealer manages the pooled fund
- Maturity restrictions: Payments are made only in specific years when the child is ready for school
- Complex contracts: Terms are difficult to understand and often not explained clearly at sale
Fee Comparison: The Real Cost
Fees compound over 18 years. Here's what different fee structures cost you:
| Plan Type | Annual Fee | Cost Over 18 Years | Impact on $50K Portfolio |
|---|
| ETF-based self-directed (e.g., XEQT) | ~0.20% MER | ~$900 | Minimal |
| Wealthsimple managed RESP | 0.40–0.50% | ~$2,000 | Small |
| Bank mutual fund RESP | 1.5–2.5% MER | ~$8,000–$14,000 | Significant |
| Group/pooled plan (all-in) | 2–4% effective | ~$100–$20,000 | Very large |
A group plan with 3% effective annual fees on a $50,000 portfolio costs you roughly $15,000–$20,000 more over 18 years compared to a low-cost ETF RESP. That's money that could have been in your child's education fund.
What to Do If You're Already in a Group RESP
If you've already signed up for a group RESP and are having second thoughts, here's what to consider:
- Review your contract carefully — understand all fees and penalties for cancellation
- Calculate your break-even point — in some cases, if you've already paid enrollment fees, staying may be better than leaving
- Contact a fee-only financial advisor — get an independent assessment of whether to stay or switch
- File a complaint if you were misled — contact the MFDA or IIROC if sales practices were inappropriate
In many cases where a family is early in the plan and fees haven't yet been fully absorbed, transferring to a self-directed RESP may still make long-term financial sense despite short-term penalties.
Opening a Self-Directed RESP in 2026
Opening a self-directed RESP is straightforward:
- Choose a provider (Wealthsimple, Questrade, or your bank)
- Open the account online in 10–15 minutes
- Provide the child's SIN and date of birth
- Set up automatic monthly contributions
- Choose your investments (or let a robo-advisor handle it)
Most Canadians are best served by a simple, diversified equity ETF portfolio when the child is young, shifting to a more conservative mix as they approach 18. Wealthsimple's managed RESP does this automatically for a 0.40–0.50% annual fee — a reasonable cost for complete hands-off management.
💰 Save More for Your Child's Education
KOHO's free savings account helps parents set aside RESP contributions every month. Earn cash back on everyday spending and redirect savings to your child's RESP.
Get KOHO Free — Code 45ET55JSYA
FAQs
Are group RESPs illegal? +
No, group RESPs are legal and regulated in Canada. However, they have faced significant regulatory action for misleading sales practices. They are not illegal but are generally considered inferior to self-directed options by most financial experts.
Can I transfer from a group RESP to a self-directed RESP? +
Yes. You can transfer an RESP between providers. However, group plan contracts often have significant early redemption fees. Review your contract before transferring to understand any penalties.
What is the best self-directed RESP provider? +
For most Canadians, Wealthsimple (managed portfolio, hands-off) or Questrade (self-directed ETFs, lowest fees) are the top choices. Major banks are convenient but tend to push higher-fee mutual funds.
Do group RESPs earn CESG? +
Yes. Both group and self-directed RESPs qualify for the CESG and CLB. The grants are deposited regardless of the plan type — the difference is only in fees and flexibility.