No fee everyday banking
Set up direct deposit and skip the monthly fee. Free to open, and the Easy plan has no monthly fee. Worth doing if you will actually move your pay or your CRA deposits over, not if the card sits unused. Code BREMO2026.
Should Canadians use 3.5%, 4%, or 4.5%? The right SWR depends on your retirement length, CPP/OAS income, and portfolio allocation. Here's the complete Canadian context.
The 4% rule comes from the 1994 Trinity Study by Cooley, Hubbard, and Walz, which analysed US stock and bond market data from 1926-1995. The study found that a portfolio of 50-75% equities could sustain inflation-adjusted 4% withdrawals for 30 years in 95%+ of historical scenarios.
Two important caveats for Canadian FIRE retirees: first, the study used US market data — Canadian markets have historically had slightly lower real returns (roughly 5-6% vs 7% for the US), primarily due to the TSX's heavy weighting in financials, energy, and materials versus the S&P 500's technology dominance. Second, the 30-year horizon assumed may be too short for Canadians retiring in their 40s or 50s — a 45-year-old retiree may need the portfolio to last 50 years.
| SWR | Best For | FIRE # for $50K/yr expenses | 30yr Success Rate (est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3% | Ultra-conservative, 50+ yr horizons | $1,667,000 | ~99% |
| 3.5% | Retiring under 50, 40-50yr horizon | $1,429,000 | ~97% |
| 4% | Retiring 50-60, 30-40yr horizon | $1,250,000 | ~95% |
| 4.5% | Retiring 60+, 25-30yr horizon | $1,111,000 | ~90% |
| 5% | Retiring 65+, traditional retirement | $1,000,000 | ~80% |
This is the most important Canadian-specific insight about safe withdrawal rates: CPP and OAS dramatically reduce the portion of expenses your portfolio must cover — and therefore reduce the risk of portfolio depletion.
A portfolio supporting $50,000/year in withdrawals over 40 years faces significant depletion risk. But a portfolio supporting $32,000/year (because CPP/OAS covers $18,000) over 40 years — and then dropping to $20,000/year as health spending declines — faces much lower risk. The effective SWR on the portfolio alone can actually be higher than 4% once government income is factored in.
Many Canadian FIRE planners use what's called a "bridge strategy": calculate a higher withdrawal rate for the pre-CPP/OAS years (accepting somewhat higher risk) with the explicit plan to reduce portfolio withdrawals dramatically once benefits begin at 65. This can allow an effectively higher SWR while maintaining long-term security.
Rigid fixed-dollar withdrawals (pure 4% rule) are not the only approach. Dynamic strategies can improve portfolio survival:
Guardrails method: Set a target withdrawal rate (4%). If portfolio drops so that actual withdrawal rate hits 5%, cut spending 10%. If portfolio grows so rate drops to 3%, allow a 10% spending increase. This flexibility dramatically improves long-term success rates.
Floor-and-ceiling: Set minimum and maximum annual spending. Never drop below $35,000/year (floor) and never spend more than $65,000/year (ceiling). Adjust within this range based on portfolio performance.
Bucket strategy: Keep 1-2 years of expenses in cash/GICs (bucket 1), 3-7 years in bonds/balanced funds (bucket 2), and the remainder in equities (bucket 3). Refill from bucket 3 to bucket 1 only when markets are up. Avoids forced selling in downturns.
Canada's tax system affects SWR planning in important ways. TFSA withdrawals are tax-free — $40,000 from TFSA is $40,000 in your pocket. RRSP/RRIF withdrawals are fully taxable — you need to withdraw $48,000-$55,000 to net $40,000 depending on province and marginal rate.
This means the "effective SWR" must account for taxes. A 4% withdrawal from a $1M RRSP generates $40,000 gross but perhaps $32,000-$35,000 after tax. Optimize by drawing TFSA first (where 4% = 4% net) and structuring RRSP meltdowns to stay in the lowest tax brackets. See our FIRE tax strategy guide.
FIRE chasers don't pay bank fees. KOHO is 100% free — no monthly fees, cash back on purchases, automatic savings roundups. Reclaim $200+/year in banking fees and invest it instead.
Get KOHO Free — Code BREMO2026