Scotiabank and CIBC are often overlooked in the Big 5 comparison wars, but they each have compelling niches. Scotiabank wins with Scene+ everyday rewards on groceries and movies. CIBC wins with lower fees, a lower fee waiver threshold, and cheaper brokerage trading. This guide compares every major category for Canadian banking customers in 2025.
| Feature | Scotiabank | CIBC |
|---|---|---|
| Basic chequing fee | $10.95/mo | $6.95/mo |
| Mid-tier fee | $16.95/mo | $14.95/mo |
| Premium fee | $30.95/mo | $29.95/mo |
| Fee waiver balance | $4,000 | $3,000 |
| ATM network | ~3,500 | ~3,400 |
| Branches | ~950 | ~1,000 |
| HISA rate | 0.01% + bonus | 0.01% |
| App Store rating | 4.7 | 4.7 |
| Google Play rating | 4.2 | 4.4 |
| Rewards program | Scene+ | Aventura |
| Student banking | Free unlimited + Scene+ | Free unlimited |
| Newcomer banking | Scotia StartRight | CIBC Smart for Newcomers |
| Brokerage trade fee | $9.99/trade (iTRADE) | $6.95/trade |
| International banking | Strong | Moderate |
CIBC has a clear pricing advantage. At every tier, CIBC is cheaper than Scotiabank — $6.95 vs $10.95 base, $14.95 vs $16.95 mid-tier, $29.95 vs $30.95 premium. The CIBC fee waiver is also $1,000 lower ($3,000 vs $4,000).
The exception is student banking, where Scotiabank earns Scene+ points on transactions — CIBC's free student account doesn't earn any points, though it does offer unlimited free transactions.
Scene+ earns points on banking, Cineplex movies, and Sobeys-family grocery shopping. This is the most practical everyday rewards program among Big 5 banks — you earn while grocery shopping, going to the movies, and just using your account.
Aventura focuses on travel. Points can be redeemed against any travel purchase (any airline, any hotel) at a transparent fixed rate. The Aventura Visa Infinite earns extra on dining and groceries.
For everyday rewards: Scotiabank Scene+ wins. For travel rewards: CIBC Aventura wins.
Scotiabank's MomentumPLUS offers a bonus rate for 90-day deposit periods. CIBC's eAdvantage Savings is similarly structured. Both post ~3.65% on 1-year GICs. Neither is competitive with EQ Bank's daily HISA rate.
Posted rates are identical. Scotiabank eHOME is a strong digital mortgage platform. CIBC has robust in-branch advisory. Both support FHSA and RRSP Home Buyers' Plan. Both are worth comparing when shopping for a mortgage.
Scotiabank wins — Scene+ points.
CIBC wins — lower fees at every tier.
CIBC wins — $6.95/trade vs $9.99.
CIBC wins — Aventura for any-airline booking.
Scotiabank wins — earns Scene+ points on transactions.
Scotiabank wins — Caribbean and Latin American network.
Even CIBC's lower fees add up. KOHO charges nothing, earns up to 5% cash back, and pays interest on your balance. Join over 1 million Canadians who've ditched bank fees.
Get KOHO Free — Code 45ET55JSYAReferral code 45ET55JSYA applied automatically.
Choose Scotiabank if you shop at Sobeys-family stores and want Scene+ grocery/movie rewards, value international Caribbean banking, or want the MomentumPLUS savings bonus.
Choose CIBC if you want lower monthly fees, a lower fee waiver, cheaper brokerage trading, flexible any-travel rewards, or are a newcomer looking for a strong banking package.