Side-by-side comparison: credit unions vs the Big Five banks. 10-year fee calculator, deposit insurance, mortgage rates, and who wins.
The fundamental difference is ownership. Banks are corporations owned by shareholders — their primary obligation is to maximize shareholder profit. Credit unions are co-operatives owned by members — every account holder is an owner, and profits are returned to members through lower fees, better rates, and community investment.
This structural difference cascades into every product and service. In 2026, the average Canadian can save $125–$2,000+ per year by switching from a Big Five bank to a credit union, depending on their banking profile.
| Institution | Type | Unlimited Monthly Fee | TFSA Rate | Deposit Insurance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| RBC Signature | Bank | $16.95 | 0.01% | CDIC ($100K/cat) |
| TD All-Inclusive | Bank | $29.95 | 0.01% | CDIC ($100K/cat) |
| Scotiabank Preferred | Bank | $16.95 | 0.01% | CDIC ($100K/cat) |
| BMO Performance | Bank | $16.95 | 0.01% | CDIC ($100K/cat) |
| CIBC Smart Plus | Bank | $29.95 | 0.01% | CDIC ($100K/cat) |
| Meridian CU | Credit Union | $10.95 | 4.5% | Unlimited (FSRA) |
| Conexus CU | Credit Union | $8–$12 | 4.3% | Unlimited (CUDIC) |
| Coast Capital | Credit Union | $0 | 4.25% | CDIC member |
Big bank TFSA rates range from 0.01% to 0.05% in 2026. The average credit union TFSA rate: 3.75%–4.5%. On $50,000 in TFSA savings, that's $1,875–$2,250 in additional interest per year at a credit union vs a bank. The compounding effect over 10 years on $50,000 is dramatic: ~$25,000+ more wealth at a credit union savings rate vs a bank rate.
Credit unions typically offer 5-year fixed mortgage rates 0.10–0.30% below big bank posted rates. On a $500,000 mortgage, 0.20% savings equals $1,000/year or $5,000 over a 5-year term. Add renewal benefits and the lifetime advantage can exceed $20,000.
Most provincial credit union deposit insurance covers 100% of all deposits with no dollar limit. CDIC covers $100,000 per account category at banks. For depositors with significant savings, the credit union advantage is substantial.
When credit unions profit, members receive patronage dividends. This is cash back on fees you paid — something no bank offers.
Big banks have ATM networks across Canada and internationally. Credit unions (except federal credit unions like Coast Capital) are typically provincial. THE EXCHANGE Network connects most Canadian credit union ATMs, but it's smaller than bank networks.
Big banks offer a wider range of premium rewards credit cards (Aeroplan, Avion, Scene+). Credit union credit cards exist but have fewer premium options. Solution: keep your credit union for banking and use KOHO or a bank credit card for spending rewards.
For Canadians who travel frequently or bank internationally, big banks have better infrastructure for wire transfers, foreign currency, and multi-country account management.
The optimal approach for most Canadians: use a credit union as your primary account (better rates, lower fees, unlimited deposit insurance), then add KOHO for daily spending (1%–2% cashback, budgeting tools, free to use). You get the best of both worlds — community banking plus modern fintech rewards.
Many Canadians keep their credit union account AND add KOHO for cash back on everyday spending. KOHO is free forever — the perfect complement to your local CU.
Get KOHO Free — Code 45ET55JSYA